Comparison Of Academic Evaluation Research At Home And Abroad Based On Journal Papers

Academic evaluation is an important link in scientific research activities,which has been a common concern in academic circles.With the rapid development of scientific research in China,the current academic evaluation system has exposed a variety of drawbacks.The long-term lack of scientific and reasonable academic evaluation system and mechanism will affect academic development.Understanding the research status of academic evaluation at home and abroad will help researchers to accurately understand the research situation of China's academic evaluation and its position and influence in the world,and enrich relevant research on academic evaluation.This study deeply analyzes the domestic and foreign academic evaluation research journal papers,compares the similarities and differences between domestic and foreign research,combs the problems in China's academic evaluation research,in order to provide reference for the related research of academic evaluation in China.In this study,the journal literature in the field of academic evaluation is taken as the research object,and the comparative analysis is conducted from the two aspects of basic situation and research content,and the domestic and foreign comparison is taken as the main line.Based on CNKI and Scopus databases,this study collects literature data of domestic and foreign academic evaluation journals,establishes a small database,and conducts empirical analysis based on this.(1)The comparative analysis of the basic situation is divided into five aspects: comparative analysis of the overall trend of academic evaluation research at home and abroad,understanding of the current development stage of academic evaluation research at home and abroad;comparative analysis of discipline distribution,research of academic evaluation knowledge radiation discipline situation;regional and institutional analysis,understanding of the current domestic and foreign main research regions and institutions,and analysis of international and regional cooperation,And draw the national citation knowledge map,analyze the national influence;comparative analysis of source publications,study the high-yield and high impact journals at home and abroad;researchers and their cooperation network,study the high-yield authors and their cooperation situation at home and abroad.(2)In the part of academic evaluation research content,draw the map of domestic and foreign research hotspots and research frontier knowledge,deeply analyze the main research contents at home and abroad,find out the current problems of academic evaluation in China through comparative analysis,and give targeted suggestions,in order to provide reference for subsequent research.