A Comparative Study On Jiang Jie's Zhu Shan Lyrics And Wang Yisun's Bi Shan Lyrics

As the early yuan dynasty adherents' lyrics,Jiang Jie's Zhu Shan lyrics and Wang Yisun's Bi Shan lyrics have similar theme contents,including the memory of the prosperous life and the lament of motherland destruction.However,Zhu Shan lyrics and Bi Shan lyrics obviously present different style.On the emotional characteristics,Zhu Shan lyrics more cool,Bi Shan lyrics more melancholy injury;On the color,Zhu Shan lyrics more bleak,Bi Shan lyrics more gorgeous;On artistic style,Zhu Shan lyrics more peculiar,Bi Shan lyrics more peaceful;On the means of expression,Zhu Shan lyrics more straight,Bi Shan lyrics more indirect.Although Jiang Jie and Wang Yisun have similar experience,same identity,but have different mentality.Involved in the realistic society and the do not contact with the realistic society in the abundant life,broad-minded and depression after motherland destruction,strong and weak under the recruit of the new dynasty,these make their lyrics present different styles.Zhu Shan lyrics and Bi Shan lyrics' accept situation also has very big difference.Yuan and Ming dynasties,Zhu Shan lyrics from implicit to explicit,Bi Shan lyrics little-known;The early years of the Qing dynasty,Yangxian lyrics genre and western Zhejiang lyrics genre consistent praise Zhu Shan lyrics and Bi Shan lyrics,but Yangxian lyrics genre attach more importance to Zhu Shan lyrics,western Zhejiang lyrics genre attach more importance to Bi Shan lyrics;The middle and later years of the Qing dynasty,Changzhou lyrics genre derogate Zhu Shan lyrics,praise highly to Bi Shan lyrics;During the period of the republic of China,new scholars affirm Zhu Shan lyrics,rebuke Bi Shan lyrics.The reason will appear this kind of circumstance,in addition to differences in lyrics for themselves,external factors also plays a big role.