| The so-called Corporation Deadlock refers to a company's effective movement failure, which can be caused by the conflict or contradiction of interest between different shareholders or corporate management personnel. The board or shareholders could not manage to hold any conference due to the rejection of their business partners; therefore, no proposal could be made by either side. And even though there is no problem with meeting process, all businesses of the company would still stay paralyzed, and so to all the bills.The formation of Corporation Deadlock can usually lead to negative influence on the company's various aspects: decision-making mechanism paralysis, management mechanism stagnation, development opportunities will be delayed, wasting of resources. Operational activities cannot be run smoothly account for operating decision is impossible to be made; because of the existed struggle, considerable time and energy of the board or shareholders are wantonly wasted, this results in tense atmosphere, weakened sense of cooperation, reduced work efficiency. Generally speaking, if the Corporation Deadlock cannot be handled correctly, it will cause the impact of security and efficiency of market transactions and become major obstacle and burden of economic society development.The harm of Corporation Deadlock requests us to establish proper judicial relief system. Corporation disbandment, rights of stockholder transfer and company separation is resolutions for Corporation Deadlock in this article; they have their own features and hold merits and demerit respectively.This article has four major sections besides the foreword and the conclusion:Section 1: introduction of Corporation Deadlock related cases and analyses. Firstly, brief the cases and raise questions. Secondly, expatiate on the plight of the case in the old judicial system and analyze the actual and form rationality of judgment of the case in the old"Law of corporation". Besides, elaborate the new"Law of corporation"related legal provisions. Finally, bring out the thinking triggered by the case. Section 2: analyzed the theory of Corporation Deadlock. Firstly, introduce the conception and negative influence on Corporation Deadlock. Secondly, classify Corporation Deadlocks. According to the main body manifestation of Corporation Deadlocks, they can be divided into three kinds: shareholders deadlock, board deadlock, institution deadlock. The two major legal systems also classified Corporation Deadlocks in order to convenient for the entrance to dispute of Corporation Deadlocks: the first is that disputes which are violates legal or the agreement duty, the judicature intervenes completely, it embodies maintenance of national public authority gives to fairness , the legal ultimate goal. The second is that Corporation Deadlock disputes which are caused by the pure commercial differences of opinion, the judicature intervenes prudently. The third is that other causes based on Corporation Deadlock disputes. Finally, analyze the influence on Corporation Deadlocks. The reasons are generally as follows: the first is diversity and conflict of main advantages , all Corporation Deadlocks are fundamentally caused by main advantages conflict. The second goes to main body's conception and difference of recognition, the world is very complicated, the recognition of the same thing, people can come to different conclusions from different roads. The third is that the corporation's own condition, corporation as an artificial person is not like nature people, It's not as natural as to take concrete action to exercise their rights obligations, only by the agencies to exercise, the company's management structure came into being, thus came into being the company's management structure, Corporate governance structure on the existence of the Corporation Deadlock left the possibility of potential. Fourth, it is the company system for defects. Fifth, the company's charter is becoming formality. Most charter company's replication according to the provisions of law or the constitution Registration Authorities maintain the format and issued by the relevant organs of the Constitution guidelines, lack of proper provisions, Loss of the company's charter should have the function and role.Section 3: compare with aboard legislation of Corporation Deadlock. Firstly, the legislation cases of Anglo-American legal system countries, their theories are based on"expect un-reached advantage theory". Secondly, the legislation case of Roman-law system countries, there is no resort caused by Corporation Deadlock dispute, Corporation Deadlocks are infrequently existed in shareholder resort, shareholder require for dismiss company resort cases and so on.Section 4, it has made the explanation to the Corporation Deadlock relief's localization. First is Corporation Deadlock beforehand prevention. Mainly elaborated the articles of incorporation in prevent the role which in the Corporation Deadlock should play, may the preset content be: First, carries on the reasonable establishment to company's government organization. Second, carries on the science design to the right to vote. For example, may stipulate the formidable shareholder, the trustee right to vote challenge system; May stipulate the limit holding shareholder right to vote exercises system; May stipulate the specific item right to vote system. Third, dismisses the power to the company to carry on the reasonable stipulation. Next, elaborated Corporation Deadlock afterward solution. Because the Corporation Deadlock in materially is company will with difficulty formation, or the company will falls into the contradictory condition to be unable to eliminate, the company will on basic is the company personality question, therefore the Corporation Deadlock's afterward key to the situation key lies in the company personality. Three different relief's way: The first way is eliminates the personality is the company dismisses, including has dismissed with the compulsion dismisses. "Law of corporation" 183rd has stipulated the solution Corporation Deadlock judicial way:"because the company the management and operation has the serious difficulty, will continue to last will cause the shareholder to suffer the heavy loss, cannot solve through other ways, will have the company complete shareholder right to vote 10% above shareholders, may request that the People's court will dissolve the company". Afterward and has given the explanation to this stipulation's imperfect place. First, the main lawsuit body plaintiff main body qualifications to be any broad? Whether to cause the right of suit to abuse? Second, not carry on to the company as well as the relative shareholder's lawsuit status is clear about the limits. Third, to the shareholder requested that dismisses the jurisdiction which the company sues not to give to be clear. Fourth, after the company dismisses, whether to deal with the company to carry on the settlement as well as the settlement procedure has not given to be clear. The company dismisses has it own malpractice: The cost is excessively high, waste resources; Overcorrects, works just the opposite. The second way is remolds'the personality is the stockholder's rights buys. The compulsion stock purchase is refers to the court to compel through the decision by a side shareholder buys another side shareholder stockholder's rights or the stock by the reasonable price, thus lets a side shareholder withdraw from the company, achieves the solution deadlock by the goal. The compulsion purchase is suitable for must carries on the transaction in the national exchange or the public stock market the company. The third way is the dissociated personality is the company establishes separately. Establishes separately first to the company with other key to the situation carries on the comparison, elaborated they respective good and bad points, then established separately to the company as the solution Corporation Deadlock way constitution important document has carried on the analysis. First, occupies the corporation stock total 10% above shareholders to propose the lawsuit request; Second, by apply for the shareholder to prove that the company reached the impasse firmly, the litigant has exhausted other ways firmly, but inextricability; Third, the company must be possible to establish separately; Fourth, must propose the reply by the company.There is no perfect resolution can deal with Corporation Deadlock, only is there the most proper resolution for particular case. When judicial institutions encounter with Corporation Deadlock related matters, they should use special details concrete study, stick to the principles, which are based on fair legal spirit and reach the maximum utility, that is the proper resolution can solve Corporation Deadlock. |
PDF Full Text Request