Analysis On The ShangBinghe's Criticisms On YuFan's Yi

YuFan and ShangBinghe are the artists of XiangShuyi. But there are many critics of YuFan in Shang's works. For example Guabian(卦变)Najia(纳甲)Zhizheng(之正)Pangtong(旁通)Select symbol and Expedient(权变).The author have taken a careful inspection in this article to study these criticism. In the part of Guaxiang(卦象)the author analyzed the seven Yixiang(易象)in whici Mr Shang and Mr Yu have significant differences. Such as'river', Mr Yu firmly believed that it is Kan. But Mr Shang firmly believed that it is Kun. Such as'moon', Mr Yu firmly believed that it is Kan. But Mr Shang firmly believed that it is Dui. Needless to say, there are too much differences in their works. Mr Shang firmly opposed to the theory of Guabian(卦变),unfortunately Mr Yu is the authority of the theory of Guabian(卦变),Mr Shang believed that Guabian is the wrong theory after the lost of Yixiang(易象).Interestingly, Mr Shang proposed his distinctive theory of Peng and Lei, which the ancient have didn't said. And Mr Shang used this theory to criticize Mr Yu. What is more, Mr Shang denied the inheritance of Han Yi(汉易的传承).He indicated that Yixiang's inheritance in the dynasty of XiHan has been lost. And YuFan's inheritance of Yi was not the inheritance of MengXi's Yi(孟氏易).But the author took a large number of survey to prove that Mr Shang's conclusion was not entirely correct. In another part of the article, the author discussed the reasons for the two experts'differences. In the last part of this article, the author applied the BoYi(帛易)to analysis the two famous experts'opinions and gave a preliminary evaluation.