Fantasizing Hermaphroditism: Two-Sexed Metaphors in Nineteenth-Century American Literature and Cultur

In nineteenth-century medicine, it was generally agreed that "true hermaphroditism," or the equal combination of male and female sexual characteristics in one body, was impossible in humans. Yet true hermaphroditism remained a significant presence in both fictional and non-fictional texts. Much of the scholarly literature is on the history of hermaphroditism as a history of intersexuality. Fantasizing Hermaphroditism: Two-Sexed Metaphors in Nineteenth-Century American Literature and Culture is a study of both hermaphroditism and the hermaphrodite as a fantasy. My approach is a combination of historicization and close reading. The chapters are in chronological order, and each chapter is centered on a single text. Chapter 1 addresses Julia Ward Howe's fictional manuscript, The Hermaphrodite ; Chapter 2, S.H. Harris' case narrative on "A Case of Doubtful Sex"; Chapter 3, James Kiernan's theoretical treatise on "Responsibility in Sexual Perversion"; and Chapter 4, a memoir by an author who went by the names Ralph Werther and Earl Lind, titled Autobiography of an Androgyne. I begin with the broader cultural moment of the text's writing, and then explore the text's language and structure in greater depth. This range of texts demonstrates that the hermaphrodite was a fantasy for nineteenth century authors, described as an impossibility but inspiring very real fear and pleasure. The language that they---and we---use in fantasies about the unreal hermaphrodite can help us to unpack these anxieties and desires around marriage, the body, race, and the definition of the individual.