Font Size: a A A

Reputation in America's graduate schools of education: A study of the perceptions and influences of graduate school of education deans and school superintendents regarding U.S. News & World Report's ranking of 'top education programs'

Posted on:2010-06-01Degree:Ph.DType:Dissertation
University:Boston CollegeCandidate:Nardone, Mary SFull Text:PDF
GTID:1447390002473515Subject:Education
Abstract/Summary:
This study explored the perceptions and influences of the respondents to the U.S. News & World Report's (USNWR) reputational survey for graduate schools of education (GSOEs). These respondents represent two unique stakeholder groups for graduate programs of education: GSOE deans and school superintendents. The existing literature regarding the USNWR rankings has been predominantly quantitative, with an emphasis on methodological problems with the rankings. This study employed mixed methods: quantitative analysis to determine the weight of the reputational surveys in the rankings, and qualitative to explore the perceptions of the raters of reputation for GSOEs.;This study highlights several unique challenges in the ranking of GSOEs, including the multiple missions and widely varying programs across schools of education. In particular the rankings fail to distinguish between the GSOE predominant dual purposes of preparing researchers and preparing practitioners. The rankings may be contributing to the divide between research and practice in the academy.;This study confirms with the GSOE deans that the rankings do matter, on and off campus, influencing the public perception of their programs. At a weighting of 40%, as stated by USWNR, reputation carries the greatest weight of all categories of input variables in the rankings. In terms of the reputational survey respondent groups, this study finds a significant difference between their levels of engagement with the rankings. This study finds a lack of meaningful participation in the rankings by the superintendents, resulting in an input variable that is biased, methodologically flawed, and contributing to erroneous fluctuations in rank. In contrast, this study finds the GSOE deans are reluctant but active participants in the rankings. They are vested competitors in the rankings business. The results indicate that the dean holds a critical role in the reputation management of their programs. These findings suggest that the rankings steer the role of the deanship toward an external focus, with an emphasis on publicizing the scholarship and scholars of the GSOE, to establish and maintain a degree of prominence among peer GSOE deans.
Keywords/Search Tags:GSOE deans, Reputation, Perceptions, Education, Rankings, Programs, Graduate, Schools
Related items
The role of brand equity in reputational rankings of specialty graduate programs in colleges of education: Variables considered by college of education deans and associate deans ranking the programs
Do rankings matter? Public school superintendents' perceptions of the Challenge Index national high school rankings and their impact on Advanced Placement program decision
Reputation and prestige in American research universities: An exploration of the history of rankings and the increasing importance of student selectivity in perceptions of quality in higher education
Have we reached the promised land of equal opportunity? An analysis of minority students' perceptions of two NSF-sponsored graduate education programs
Deans of students as crisis managers: Perceptions of roles and leadership competencies in 12 public higher education institutions in Florida
The evolving role of research in Mexican graduate programs in the field of education: A case study of six selected programs (1980-1992)
Research On University Rankings From The Perspective Of Symbolic Power Theory ——Take The Four Major World University Rankings As An Example
Critical institutional leadership challenges for the 21st century for public doctoral-granting institutions: Perceptions of selected Illinois senior-level university administrators and college deans
The Study Of The Continuing Education And Training Of Deans Of Teaching Affairs In Primary And Middle Schools In H County,Zhejiang Province
10 Research On The Strategy Of Promoting The Reputation Of Private High School Brand