Comparative Efficacy And Safety Of Therapy For The Behavioral And Psychological Symptoms Of Dementia:A Systemic Review And Bayesian Network Meta-analysis

Objective: To assess the comparative efficacy and safety of both pharmacological and non-pharmacological therapies for the behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia(BPSD),using direct and indirect evidence from randomized data.Method: A systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis(NMA)was conducted on only randomized controlled trials(RCTs)of all the available interventions for BPSD.RCTs were selected from Pubmed,EMBASE,the Cochrane library and CINAHL.The efficacy outcomes were Neuropsychiatric Inventory(NPI)and Cohen-Mansfield Agitation Inventory(CMAI).The outcomes of safety were total adverse events(AEs),diarrhea,dizziness,headache,falls,nausea,vomiting and cerebrovascular diseases.Result: 146 RCTs comprising 44873 patients with BPSD were included in this study.On NPI,aripiprazole(MD=-3.65,95% credible interval(CrI)=-6.92 to-0.42),escitalopram(MD=-6.79,95%CrI=-12.91 to-0.60),donepezil(MD=-1.45,95%CrI=-2.70 to-0.20),galantamine(MD=-1.80,95%CrI=-3.29 to-0.32),memantine(MD=-2.14,95%CrI=-3.46 to-0.78)and risperidone(MD=-3.20,95%CrI=-6.08 to-0.31)were superior to placebo.On CMAI,aripiprazole(MD=-4.00,95%CrI=-7.39 to-0.54)and risperidone(MD=-2.58,95%CrI=-5.20 to-0.6)showed superiority to placebo.On the risk of total AEs,donepezil(OR=1.27,95%CrI=1.07 to 1.50),galantamine(OR=1.91,95%CrI=1.58 to 2.36),risperidone(OR=1.47,95%CrI=1.13-1.97)and rivastigmine(OR=2.02,95%CrI=1.53-2.70)owned higher risk than placebo.Conclusion: Pharmacological therapies should be the first choice for BPSD.Aripiprazole,haloperidol,quetiapine,and risperidone of antipsychotics showed the significant efficacy,while memantine,galantine and donepezil may provide the modest effectiveness.The safety of all was thought to be acceptable.